Key to 15 Saddle-like and Lobed (Noncupulate) Taxa of Helvella in North America 
| 2. | Cap dark brown or reddish brown or purplish red, 2- to 3-lobed; growing on wood (or, rarely, terrestrially, especially in the West); stem smooth or broadly wrinkled; undersurface of cap not hairy; spores with two oil droplets. | |
| 2. | Not completely as above. | 3 |
| 3. | Cap brown, cushion-shaped; growing on wood; stem ribbed, with pink to purplish shades. | |
| 3. | Not completely as above. | 4 |
| 4. | Stem with sharply defined ribs. | 5 |
| 4. | Stem smooth, wrinkled, broadly grooved once, or with a few folds at its base--but without sharply defined ribs. | 11 |
| 5. | Cap white or whitish. (See also a form of Helvella sulcata.) | 6 |
| 5. | Cap brown, gray, or black. | 7 |
| 6. | Cap edges becoming intergrown with the stem by maturity; undersurface of cap under a hand lens smooth or nearly so. | |
| 6. | Cap edges never becoming intergrown with the stem; undersurface of cap under a hand lens finely hairy or fuzzy. | |
| 7. | Cap brown; undersurface of cap densely hairy. | |
| 7. | Cap gray to black; undersurface smooth or nearly so. (Helvella lacunosa in the wide sense--or in the strict sense, according to some authors who treat the subsequent species as varieties.) | 8 |
| 8. | Cap more or less convex or cushion-shaped. | |
| 8. | Cap saddle-shaped, lobed, or irregular. | 9 |
| 9. | Cap saddle-shaped or 3-lobed; undersurface of cap without ribs or wrinkles; growing on rotting wood (rarely terrestrially) in upland woods. | |
| 9. | Cap variously shaped; undersurface of cap with ribs or wrinkles; growing in wet areas (bogs, among damp mosses, and so on) or on disturbed ground (roadbanks, landscaped areas, ditches, and the like). | 10 |
| 10. | Stem small (to 6 cm long and 1 cm thick), with blunt ribs that do not form holes and pockets; cap nearly always loosely saddle-shaped. | |
| 10. | Stem substantially larger than above, with sharp-edged ribs that form holes and pockets; cap ranging from saddle-shaped to irregularly lobed and folded. | |
| 11. | Cap and stem black or nearly so. | 12 |
| 11. | Cap and stem variously colored, but not both black. | 13 |
| 12. | Undersurface of cap densely hairy or fuzzy; cap margin strongly inrolled when young and remaining somewhat inrolled through maturity. | |
| 12. | Undersurface of cap smooth or very finely fuzzy; cap margin not usually strongly inrolled. | |
| 13. | Cap margin never rolled upwards; undersurface of cap smooth or nearly so; stem hollow. | |
| 13. | Cap margin usually strongly rolled upwards when young (and sometimes in maturity); undersurface of cap fuzzy or hairy, at least when young; stem hollow or not. | 14 |
| 14. | Mushroom quite small at maturity (cap no wider than 2 cm, stem no thicker than .5 cm); stem brownish or grayish; undersurface of cap densely hairy. | |
| 14. | Mushroom larger than above at maturity; stem whitish; undersurface finely fuzzy, or smooth by maturity. | 15 |
| 15. | Cap black; stem white; fruiting in winter and spring in California, under Narrowleaf Cottonwood. | "Helvella leucopus" sensu Arora |
| 15. | Not completely as above. | 16 |
| 16. | Cap medium brown to dark brown; undersurface of cap densely and conspicuously hairy; found primarily in the Pacific Northwest and on the West Coast, fruiting from March to December. | |
| 16. | Cap variously colored; undersurface of cap finely fuzzy or nearly smooth; variously distributed. | 17 |
| 17. | Cap pale brown to medium brown; fruiting from early summer through fall in eastern North America and in the Canadian Rockies; spores 16-21 µ long. | |
| 17. | Cap medium brown to dark brown; fruiting in late summer and fall across North America; spores 18-24 µ long. | |
Note: Cudonia circinans looks a lot like a species of Helvella until microscopic analysis reveals its amazing, needle-like spores.
References
Abbott, S. O. & Currah, R. S. (1997). The Helvellaceae: Systematic revision and occurrence in northern and northwestern North America. Mycotaxon 62: 1-125.
Arora, D. (1986). Mushrooms demystified: A comprehensive guide to the fleshy fungi. Berkeley: Ten Speed Press. 959 pp.
Batra, L. R. (1976). Helvella and Gyromitra (Pezizales: Operculatae) in the southern Appalachians. In B. C. Parker & M. K. Roane, eds. Distributional history of the biota of the southern Appalachians. Part IV. Algae & fungi: biogeography, systematics and ecology. Charlottesville, Virginia: University Press of Virginia. 145-204.
Dissing, H. & Lange, M. (1967). Notes on the genus Helvella in North America. Mycologia 59: 349-360.
Kanouse, B. B. (1946). Some studies in the genus Helvella. Papers of the Michigan Academy of Science, Arts and Letters 32: 83-90.
Treibs, H. A. (2001). Trial key to Helvellaceae in the Pacific Northwest. Retrieved January 22, 2005 from the Pacific Northwest Key Council Web site: http://www.svims.ca/council/Helvel.htm
Weber, N. S, (1972). The genus Helvella in Michigan. The Michigan Botanist 11: 147-201.
Weber, N. S, (1975). Notes on western species of Helvella. I. Beihefte Nova Hedwigia 51: 25-38.
Cite this page as:
Kuo, M. (2005, January). Saddles: The genus Helvella. Retrieved from the MushroomExpert.Com Web site: http://www.mushroomexpert.com/helvella.html
© MushroomExpert.Com