Traditionally, two families of stinkhorns were recognized. The Phallaceae held stinkhorns with unbranched stems, including species of Mutinus, Phallus, and Dictyophora (now synonymized with Phallus), among others. The Clathraceae included stinkhorns with branched stems and those with funky, latticed structures--including Clathrus, Lysurus, Colus, Laternea, and others. Although the current Dictionary of the Fungi contradicts itself on the status of these two stinkhorn families (the entry for the order Phallales includes the Phallaceae but not the Clathraceae, while the entry for the Clathraceae indicates it belongs in the Phallales) it is rather a moot point, since recent DNA research has indicated that the order Phallales also includes many coral mushrooms, species of Gomphus like Gomphus floccosus, and earthstars like Geastrum saccatum. See the page for the Phallales for further information.
Key to 25+ North American Stinkhorns
Note: Some species from Central America have been included on the assumption that they may range into tropical and subtropical regions of North America. Some non-North American stinkhorns are treated at the site, but not in the key below. They include Clathrus baumii, Clathrus transvaalensis, Colus pusillus, Ileodictyon cibarium, Ileodictyon gracile, Phallus aurantiacus, Phallus cinnabarinus, Phallus multicolor, and Lysurus corallocephalus. It should also be noted that stinkhorns are notorious for appearing where they are not supposed to appear, geographically, since they are easily spread through human endeavors.
|1.||Spore slime occurring on a ring (reminiscent of a napkin ring) near the top of a white stinkhorn with Swiss-cheese-like holes; subtropical to tropical.|
|2.||Spore slime occurring near the top of an unbranched structure (a stem that does not split into separate arms, columns, claws, or tentacles), on the outer surface.|
|2.||Spore slime occurring on the inner (rarely on the outer) surfaces of a branched, latticed, or columned structure which may or may not sit on top of a stem.|
|3.||Without a clearly distinct "head" or "cap" to bear the spore slime (in other words, the spore slime merely covers the surface of the stem, usually toward the top).|
|3.||With a distinct "head" or "cap," separated from the stem (but possibly collapsing against it), bearing the spore slime.|
|4.||Mature stem orange or reddish orange.|
|4.||Mature stem without orange shades: pink, red, or white.|
|5.||Spore slime covering only 2–3 cm, the tip of the stem abruptly rounded; spores 3.5–5 x 1.5–2 µm.|
|5.||Spore slime covering more than 2–3 cm, the stem gracefully tapering to a point; spores 4–7 x 2–3 µm.|
|6.||Stinkhorn narrowing substantially toward a somewhat pointy tip that is often pale and often becomes perforated; "spore slime zone" covering one-half to two-thirds of the stinkhorn; surface dark red underneath the spore slime; tropical in distribution.|
|6.||Stinkhorn not as pointy as above, not usually becoming perforated at the tip; "sSpore slime zone" covering one-fourth to one-third of the stinkhorn; surface color varying; variously distributed.|
|7.||Mature stem white (all the way to the apex, under the slime); originally described from Oregon, recorded from Michigan (range undetermined).|
|7.||Mature stem dark rose pink above, rose pink to whitish below; rather stocky; stem surface with large pits; common in northeastern North America.|
|8.||Mature stinkhorn with a netted "skirt" (reminiscent of a doily on your grandmother's coffee table) hanging from the cap.|
|8.||Mature stinkhorn lacking a "skirt."|
|9.||Skirt 3-6 cm long, not extending to the ground; fairly common in eastern North America.|
|9.||Skirt longer than above, often extending nearly to the ground; likely to occur only in tropical and subtropical locations or in greenhouses.|
|10.||Fresh, mature stinkhorn with a red, pink, or orange stem.|
|10.||Fresh, mature stinkhorn with a whitish stem.|
|11.||Stem red to pink, up to 2.5 cm thick; distributed from the southeastern states to Texas, Oklahoma, and Colorado.|
|11.||Stem orange, under 2 cm thick; fairly widely distributed in the United States but most common in the Midwest and Mid-Atlantic states.|
|12.||Cap smooth or finely granular beneath the spore slime; found east of the Rocky Mountains.|
|12.||Cap pitted and ridged beneath the spore slime; eastern or western in distribution.|
|14.||With a more or less central, single (not composite) stem that is clearly visible above the volva for at least a few centimeters; the stem may then split into columns or tentacles (which may or may not rejoin at the very top), or it may support a latticed structure.|
|14.||Central stem if present composite, composed of multiple arms fused together--or stem absent or rudimentary, not extending more than a centimeter above the volva.|
|14.||Stem more or less round in cross-section.|
|16.||Stem holding aloft a pointed structure that lacks prominent cross-lattices--or stem branching into vertical arms, appearing like claws or tentacles, that may fold back by maturity.|
|17.||Stem holding aloft a pointed structure with 4-6 short columns (under 4 cm long) that are firmly fused at their tips at first but may separate slightly at maturity.|
|17.||Stem terminating with 3-22 long arms (longer than 4 cm) that may or may not be joined at their tips initially, but by maturity may be separated and spread out like octopus or squid tentacles.|
|18.||Claws covered with spore slime all the way to their bases, almost always separating and folding back somewhat by maturity; reported from Ohio and Kansas, and to be expected throughout subtropical and tropical North America.|
|18.||Claws covered with spore slime except at their bases, rarely separating or folding back at maturity; reported from Asia and Africa.|
|19.||Arms or tentacles thin, numbering 5-22, never connected at the top; spore slime covering the disc between the tentacles, or the bases of the tentacles (or both), but not extending to their tips.|
|19.||Arms or tentacles fairly thick, numbering 3-7, initially connected at the top; spore slime covering inner/upper surfaces of arms, all the way to their tips.|
|20.||Arms numbering 4-7, usually separating and peeling back almost to the ground by maturity; documented from California; spores 4-7.5 x 2-2.5 µ.|
|20.||Arms numbering 3-4, usually remaining fused at their tips or peeling back only slightly by maturity; documented from northeastern North America and Kansas, to be expected across the continent; spores 3.5-4.5 x 1.5-2 µ.|
|21.||Stinkhorn consisting of a cage-like structure, with horizontal cross-lattices (at least near the top of the structure) in addition to vertical lattices.|
|21.||Stinkhorn without horizontal cross-lattices, consisting only of vertical columns which may or may not be fused at their tips--and which may or may not peel back at maturity to appear like the arms of an octopus or squid.|
|22.||Cross-lattices numerous, but only occurring at the top of the stinkhorn, held aloft by 4-6 vertical columns which are often fused together into a stemlike structure; reported from Jamaica.|
|22.||Cross-lattices not restricted to the top of the stinkhorn; variously distributed.|
|23.||Cross-lattices rare, only occasionally occurring between 2-5 thick, vertical columns that are fused at their tips.|
|23.||Cross-lattices frequent, creating a cage-like appearance.|
|24.||Growing in Florida and along the Gulf Coast; holes in the cage surrounded by "coronas" (see the photos on the page linked to the right); spores about 4 µ long.|
|24.||Growing on the West Coast, or in Mexico, or in the Caribbean; holes lacking coronas; spores 4-6 µ long.|
|25.||Stinkhorn a red to orangish cage-like structure; growing in California (especially in the Bay Area) and Mexico.|
|25.||Stinkhorn a bright yellow cage-like structure; documented in Cuba and Jamaica.|
|26.||Spore slime borne only on a structure (a "glebifer") that hangs at the top of the stinkhorn, under the arches formed by vertical columns which are fused at their tips.|
|26.||Spore slime not limited to an apical glebifer.|
|27.||Columns not crested.|
|28.||Columns white to pale beige when fresh; documented from Texas and Mexico.|
|28.||Columns not white to pale beige when fresh; variously distributed.|
|29.||Columns whitish to pale beige; outer sides with grooves; known from Mexico.|
|29.||Columns white; outer sides without grooves; known from Texas, the Caribbean, Africa, and South America.|
|30.||Spore slime confined to the upper portion of the interior surfaces of the columns (rarely lower than the top half).|
|30.||Spore slime covering the entire interior surfaces of the columns, from top to bottom.|
|31.||Stinkhorn with 2-5 columns up to 15 cm tall; reddish to orangish; occasionally with a cross-lattice or two; distributed from New York to the Gulf States, Illinois, and Mexico; especially common in Florida.|
|31.||Stinkhorn with 2 columns up to 9 cm tall; orangish or yellowish; without cross-lattices; recorded from California.|
|32.||Arms numbering 4-7, usually separating and peeling back almost to the ground by maturity; documented from California.|
|32.||Arms numbering 3-6, remaining fused at their tips or peeling back only slightly by maturity; variously distributed.|
|33.||Arms numbering 3-6; outer surfaces grooved; edges of arms appearing toothed; known from Mexico and the Caribbean southward.|
|33.||Arms numbering 3-4; outer surfaces not grooved; edges of arms not appearing toothed; documented from northeastern North America to Kansas, to be expected across the continent.|
Abrar, S., S. Swapna & M. Krishnappa (2012). Development and morphology of Lysurus cruciatus—an addition to the Indian mycobiota. Mycotaxon 122: 217–282.
Acharya, K., P. Pradhan, N. Chakraborty, A. K. Dutta, S. Saha, S. Sarkar & S. Giri (2010). Two species of Lysurus Fr.: addition to the macrofungi of West Bengal. Journal of the Botanical Society of Bengal 64: 175–178.
Alves, C. R. & V. G. Cortez (2016). Gasteroid Phallomycetidae (Basidiomycota) from the Parque Estadual São Camilo, Paraná, Brazil. Iheringia Serie Botanica 71: 27–42.
Arora, D. & W. Burk (1982). Clathrus archeri, a stinkhorn new to North America. Mycologia 74: 501–504.
Blanton, R. L. & W. Burk (1980). Notes on Pseudocolus fusiformis. Mycotaxon 12: 225–234.
Burk, W. R. (1979). Clathrus ruber in California and worldwide distributional records. Mycotaxon 8: 463–468.
Calonge, F. D., G. Guzmán & F. Ramírez-Guillén (2004). Observaciones sobre los Gasteromycetes de México depositados en los herbarios XAL y XALU. Boletín de la Sociedad Micológica de Madrid 28: 337–372.
Calonge, F. D. (2005). A tentative key to identify the species of Phallus. Boletín de la Sociedad Micológica de Madrid 29: 9–17.
Calonge, F. D., M. Mata & J. Carranza (2005). Contribución al catálogo de los Gasteromycetes (Basidiomycotina, Fungi) de Costa Rica. Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid 62: 23–45.
Coetzee, J. C. (2010). Taxonomic notes on the Clathraceae (Phallales: Phallomycetidae) sensu Bottomley and a new key to the species in southern Africa. Bothalia 40: 155–159.
Coker, W. C. & J. N. Couch (1928). The Gasteromycetes of the eastern United States and Canada. North Carolina: University of North Carolina Press (Dover reprint, 1974).
Cortez, V. G., I. G. Baseia & R. M. B. da Silveria (2011). Gasteroid mycobiota of Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil: Lysuraceae (Basidiomycota). Maringá 33: 87-92.
Cunningham, G. H. (1944/1979). The gasteromycetes of Australia and New Zealand. Germany: J. Cramer.
Desjardin, D. E. & B. A. Perry (2009). A new species of Phallus from São Tomé, Africa. Mycologia 101: 545–547.
Dring, D. M. (1964). Gasteromycetes of West Tropical Africa. Mycological Papers 98: 1–59.
Dring, D. M. & R. W. Rayner (1967). Some gasteromycetes from eastern Africa. Journal of the East Africa Natural History Society 26: 5–46.
Dring, D. M. & A. C. Rose (1977). Additions to West African phalloid fungi. Kew Bulletin 31: 741–751.
Dring, D. M. (1980). Contributions toward a rational arrangement of the Clathraceae. Kew Bulletin 35: 1–96.
Gogoi, G. & V. Parkash (2014). Some new records of stinkhorns (Phallaceae) from Hollongapar Gibbon Wildlife Sanctuary, Assam, India. Journal of Mycology 490847, 8 pp.
Gogoi, G. & V. Parkash (2015). Lysurus habungianus sp. nov. (Phallaceae)—a new stinkhorn fungus from India. Current Research in Environmental & Applied Mycology 5: 248–255.
Guzmán, G. (1984). Nuevos registros de Lysurus periphragmoides de México. Boletín de la Sociedad Mexicana de Micología 19: 169–171.
Guzmán, G., L. Montoya & V. M. Bandala (1990). Las especies y formas de Dictyophora (Fungi, Basidiomycetes, Phallales) en México y observaciones sobre su distribucion en america latina. Acta Botanica Mexicana 9: 1–11.
Hemmes, D. E. & D. E. Desjardin (2009). Stinkhorns of the Hawaiian islands. Fungi 2: 8–10.
Hernández Caffot, M. L., K. Hosaka, L. S. Domínguez & C. Urcelay (2018). Molecular and morphological data validate the new combination of Lysurus sphaerocephalum from Argentina, with some additional records on Phallales (Agaricomycetes). Mycologia 110: 419–433.
Hosaka, K., S. T. Bates, R. E. Beever, M. A. Castellano, W. Colgan III, L. S. Dominguez, E. R. Nouhra, J. Geml, A. J. Giachini, S. R. Kenney, N. B. Simpson, J. W. Spatafora & J. M. Trappe (2006). Molecular phylogenetics of the gomphoid-phalloid fungi with an establishment of the new subclass Phallomycetidae and two new orders. Mycologia 98: 949–959.
Hosaka, K. (2010). Preliminary list of Phallales (Phallomycetidae, Basidiomycota) in Taiwan. Memoirs of the National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo 46: 57–64.
Hosaka, K. (2012). Preliminary list of Phallales (Phallomycetidae, Basidiomycota) in Thailand. Memoirs of the National Museum of Nature and Science, Tokyo 48: 81–89.
Jackson, G. & J. Webster (1972). Growth of Phallus aurantiacus from cattle dung. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 59: 332–333.
Kreisel, H. (1996). A preliminary survey of the genus Phallus sensu lato. Czech Mycology 48: 273–281.
Lécuru, C., J. Mornand, J. -P. Fiard, P. -A. Moreau & R. Courtecuisse (2013). Clathrus roseovolvatus, a new phalloid fungus from the Caribbean. Cryptogamie, Mycologie 34: 35–44.
Lee, W. S. (1957). Two new phalloids from Taiwan. Mycologia 49: 156–158.
Lloyd, C. G. (1909). Synopsis of the known phalloids. Bulletin of the Lloyd Library 13: 1–96.
Long, W. H. (1907). The Phalloideae of Texas. Journal of Mycology 13: 102–114.
Oso, B. A. (1976). Phallus aurantiacus from Nigeria. Mycologia 68: 1076–1082.
Pegler, D., T. Laessoe & B. Spooner (1995). British puffballs, earthstars and stinkhorns. Royal Botanic gardens, Kew. 255 pp.
Petch, T. (1926). Mutinus bambusinus (Zoll.) Ed. Fischer. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 10: 272–282.
Rea, P. M. (1955) The genus Lysurus. Papers of the Michigan Academy of Science 40: 49–66.
Sáenz, J. A. & Nassar, C. M. (1982). Hongos de Costa Rica: Familias Phallaceae y Clathraceae. Revista de Biologia Tropical 30: 41–52.
Sandoval-Leiva, P., Henríquez, J. L. & L. Trierveiler-Pereira (2014). Additions to Chilean phalloid mycota. Mycotaxon 128: 45–54.
da Silva, B. D. B., T. S. Cabral, M. P. Martín, P. Marinho, F. D. Calonge & I. G. Baseia (2015). Mutinus albotruncatus (Phallales, Agaricomycetes), a new phalloid from the Brazilian semiarid, and a key to the world species. Phytotaxon 236: 237–248.
Smith, A. H. (1951). Puffballs and their allies in Michigan. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. 131 pp.
Trierveiler-Pereira, L., R. M. B. da Silva & K. Hosaka (2014). Multigene phylogeny of the Phallales (Phallomycetidae, Agaricomycetes) focusing on some previously unrepresented genera. Mycologia 106: 904–911.
Vargas-Rodriguez, Y. L. & J. A. Vázquez-García (2005). Blumenavia toribiotalpaensis: a new species of Clathraceae from Jalisco, Mexico. Mycotaxon 94: 7–14.
Zeller, S. M. (1944). A white variety of Mutinus caninus. Mycologia 36: 263–265.
This site contains no information about the edibility or toxicity of mushrooms.
Cite this page as:
Kuo, M. (2011, April). Stinkhorns: Phallaceae and Clathraceae. Retrieved from the MushroomExpert.Com Web site: http://www.mushroomexpert.com/phallaceae.html